As I’m sure you know, if you’ve been reading my column for a while now, I have, for my sins, been running a long-term Mage: The Ascension game. It’s been a very off-kilter game, to say the least, with players essentially on a long, errant barge and bus trip around the 90’s United Kingdom while uncovering the secrets of various locations, from Whitby’s Goth hollow ones to Stratford-Upon-Avon’s deadly theatre brainwashing Technocrats to the urban Faeries of Camden Lock and all that’s in between. So far it’s all been like a sandbox set in the country I live in at a time I was growing up. It’s been full of whimsy, social commentary and some severely weird magic.
But a couple of sessions ago it went a bit wrong. Two players had an in-character discussion about the morality of fleecing a front-line theatre worker in order to get into a performance for free. I’ll spare the details, but one player felt confused about the way another player chose to raise the argument, and the line between players and characters blurred a little for a moment. There was an argument that I think made a few people feel uncomfortable. No out-of-character shouting or anything, but in character, the confused character got very upset and left the theatre, followed out by a few others. Then some other characters stayed. Yet a third group decided this wasn’t too much heat for them and left the theatre for a meal. I was left with three groups. This in itself wasn’t too bad. But then the dice and choices told a story which led to significant ruin.

Fall Of Magic
The confused player and her allies decided they needed to work off some steam and went to a posh riverboat clubhouse they knew was owned by some sketchy people. Some game time later, one of the players had been thrown down some stairs and had to flee through a plate-glass window as others poured magic onto…something…guarding the inside. As the rest of the group arrived back, there was a full-scale retreat, with players fleeing either in a river barge or car they both owned, regrouping at a pub garden downriver.
This also went badly when the mage the group usually relied on for healing, a mind-over-body alternative medicine self-help guru, failed their role, and the backlash from the magic turned their eyes to glass. Through the screaming, two of the group had to work together fast to change the elemental and biological magics to rebuild an eye. By the end of the game, the players felt the same as their characters. Harried, tired and divided. I closed the session and felt worried that this might be the direction of the game going forward. Division, stress and chaotic flight.
So how, by the end of the next session, had we fixed everything? How can healing happen at a table? Well, here’s what happened for me, which might serve as a roadmap for you if you have a fallout at your table and need to smooth things over in and out of character.
Rebuilding The Trust
So here’s something you don’t want to do if your players have an argument at the table. Next session, you know it needs resolving, but you do not want to just re-wade into the same argument. So in between, I checked in with both players and allowed them to air their feelings. When I’d worked out it was just a genuine difference of outlook about play that could be resolved by adults, I let people know it was going to be given space, but I didn’t dive straight back into the conflict right away. Why not?
Well, people aren’t yet fully in the game when they arrive. They need a little time to be able to just adjust themselves. So instead I opened with the healer waking up in a room in the pub and really ratcheted the tension by bombarding them with trauma from things they had done previously, really ratcheted up the tension. This was to shake people into the story. I kept the two upset parties on the sidelines of this action, allowing them to feel the world again.
I then, at the first available opportunity, introduced a humour element. This allowed the players to relax slightly, moving past the tension of the last session. The players knew that a discussion would be coming, but they were now beginning to trust the world again. Another player had accidentally pulled a pub door off and sort of given extra dimensions so it wouldn’t fit back in the frame without sort of looking like an Escher painting. They were panicking that people would find out, and the next hour became about me flitting between players, doing set pieces that allowed NPCs and player characters to get somewhere near friends again.
Then, after I was sure this wasn’t going to be a shouting match, I positioned the whole group together with an NPC in the mix. The reason for this is simple – it might seem like just having the two characters have a scene alone would be a good apology idea. And if it were just in character, then maybe I’d have done this. But for an event where the players themselves are hurting and are going to discuss it, you need a buffer. And the buffer here was the other players, who wanted to make sure none of their friends was sad while playing this game and would defuse things if they got too heated. Just in case, I had the NPC who was there so I could also have a hand in steering the discussion out of emotionally hurtful places by having them interject with humour or middle-ground points.

And what followed was an hour of me watching players heal their own play group. Through listening to each other, putting their points across and being vulnerable with each other. And it became a conversation about how the group was starting to fracture. How they’d been thrown together, but all needed to learn to support each other despite the fact they were very different people with very different belief systems. It ended in a ritual in which the originally confused mage used magic consensually to strengthen the metaphorical bond between them.
At this point, I did what I needed to; I first congratulated them out of character, letting the players know I had just watched them navigate a hard and complicated discussion. Then I rewarded them in-game with a Willpower point each. This was both because I know giving an in-game reward for behaviour is solid ‘good job’ dopamine for players and because I was overcome with emotion for my friend group’s ability to really know each other. It felt like a significant moment for not only the mages, but us as people.
I’m hoping that, in this moment of healing for our group, you can see the steps taken and managed to help you if you have a fixable falling out in your group. It won’t work for everyone, and the important thing is to begin by fixing things outside of the game first. But this hopefully provides the ghost of a blueprint if you then want to not just gloss over things and instead move towards in-character resolution too. It’s honestly worth sacrificing the plot for a week to give players time to check in with each other and reset.
Until next time, have fun and be good to each other.
Creative Commons credit: The Legendary Golems by Ry-Spirit and Princess Lyonesse by ArtistIssues.