Last night, my D&D game was nearing the end of an arc that had run for over two years, taking on a villain that was introduced roughly five years ago in the campaign. The players had just survived a series of hardcore encounters and were planning to return to the court of their enemy, The Lord Judgement and, under the nose of his staff and guards and baying crowds, perform an assassination, escaping before he or anyone else could release the Rust Mother, his huge acid-spewing bug pet. This of course, sounds like an epic battle to come and a serious, intense moment in the campaign.

Except of course, this is my Lazer Valkyries campaign and the players in this world are…unique. Over the last five years, they’ve helped create a world that is part Conan, part Mad Max, part She-Ra and very queer. So their plan to get in front of The Lord Judgement is…a fashion show. With costumes designed in sparkling tinfoil by famous Goblin Fashion designer Sticki Worril, owner of Worril’s Kitchen. It will be accompanied by car-sized metallic dancing scorpions because they forgot they had a ring of scaladar controlling on their person until just this planning session. Once equipped, they then proceeded to enter themselves into a talent show for Lord Judgement’s arena, performing a rehearsal of a fabulous dance number complete with magical pyrotechnics in front of a cloaked cyborg judge known as Mr.Cowl.
So, instead of a tense session plotting the downfall of a heinous enemy in the ruined Redbelt city of Junktown, last night’s session became ‘The Redbelt’s Got Talent‘. As I sat there, I realised my players’ mood had upended every expectation I had for the session and shifted the mood of the campaign. I was going to need to open the next session with this mood before needing to shift it abruptly back to a dangerous fight so they could all feel narratively satisfied with this showdown, then I realised something.
AI is never going to be able to do any of this. It’s never going to be able to read when players are subconsciously leaning towards whimsy when it’s been serious up until a few seconds ago. It’s never going to have a mad idea in the middle of the session and create an on-the-spur-of-the-moment robot Simon Cowell rip-off, and it’s not going to realise it needs to shift the tone soon to meet needs players don’t realise they need in order to feel fulfilled. I’ve been worried recently about the idea an AI might eventually make my job as a Professional GM obsolete. But I just realised how much of the job is reading the people in the moment, without them telling you what they want. It is an integral part of running these games.
What I love about RPGs is that moment of connection, where you’re all having a moment. Be it one of emotional depth or being silly together. It’s not actually about the plot; it’s about the human being at the table bringing something you didn’t expect. The reaction that is not the next logical thing but instead the thing that is human is weird and personal. So in honour of being human, here’s a list of plays you can make as a thinking meat-body person in order to bring the thing your players come back to your games for. Your beautiful and slightly deranged mind.
Long Game And Foreshadowing
As a GM with a plan, you’re not always just trying to just provide the most likely response. Yes, that is the basic function of a GM, but actually you’re a person with long-term goals. You can always be looking backwards and forwards in a game. Remember to let stuff that you have planned in the future bleed into the stuff you’re doing now – let the plot feel connected so that players can see the human ideas behind your game are there. I recently had a player in my Crone Kingdoms game realise they were now planning to dress exactly like a future version of themselves they’d met in a plot two years ago, and the reaction they had when they realised they’d closed the circle was amazing. Remember that a tool you have as a person is long-term memory and planning. Introduce stuff and then tie it back in later, deepening continuity in a way that makes sense.
Whimsy/Juxtaposition
If you have a daft idea at the right moment, just go with it. It’ll likely be the bit everyone remembers anyway. Moments when the mood switches from comedy to serious and back again are a core part of creating something human and usually sear themselves into players’ minds. Our mood and tone are only set if we want them to be. If you an idea that instantly drops plot onto the mood and elements that weren’t there a second ago, go with it. Revel in the ideas that aren’t just doing what was most likely to come next but instead the least likely thing. RPGs at their core are games of the unexpected path. Keep this tradition alive.

Listening And Context
As a person who is in a game with other people, you need to learn what they are telling you through action or moment. What they’re actually searching for. You can tell when a player is taking an action, looking for things to go completely off the rails, or when they are instead feeling low and need you to soft-ball the session for them. Or when they’re looking for emotional catharsis.
But also, you know about context here. Just because the players have fallen in love with a bartender NPC, you don’t want to make all the focus about them and make them the centre of the story. You can just keep them a nice and stable part of the world, with small changes. You know when to add something to your world they’re seeking; you know when to make a place feel like a stable home by keeping it the same.
Detail Crunch
You know that too much florid description is just as bad as no description. You know when to use a thousand words; you know when too many words are going to be more confusing. You don’t need to add detail to every element of a world, because you know the intent of a scene. The shopkeeper needs to have one trait and provide the information they need, or develop a second trait if the conversation goes on long enough. Sometimes it’s about worldbuilding. But you know when it’s about brevity and when those player needs change. Keep them in mind.
Vulnerability
Lastly, you can be vulnerable. Let people know you’re telling a story that matters to you. Get involved and enjoy the experience; it will be infectious. Be honest and talk with your players outside of the game about the bits you loved, the moments they gave to you. Always take that moment in-game to hear how the characters feel about a moment at the table. Shift the spotlight to someone who hasn’t been in it for a while. Give something of yourself to your worlds. You’re all here to share being in this space together. Be a fan of the thing you are all making. Let others be part of your inner life and reward what they add to it.
As you might have guessed, I’m a real fan of humanity. We sometimes lose the idea in running a ‘perfect game’ that the best game is a slightly off-kilter one where we learn about the people we are playing with and what they value in their stories. Until next time, I hope you all get to know each other better.
Creative Commons credit: post apocalyptic gang by carloscara and TWST – Kazuo (SR) Lab Coats by ThatLethalSoul.