A simulation of 316,800 one-on-one Dungeons & Dragons (2024 rules) duels by Gabor Szalai at The Long Table ranks the Sorcerer and the Monk as the strongest single-combat classes, while finding that the Fly spell rarely decides outcomes.
Published on 6 November 2026 to demonstrate The Long Table’s browser-based encounter simulator, the study pitted all twelve core 2024 classes against one another across levels 1 to 20 from starting distances of 30, 60, and 90 feet. Across the primary 60-foot benchmark, comprising 105,600 individual fights, the Sorcerer won 79% of its matches, and the Monk won 75%, leaving the Wizard in a distant third place at 62%.

Methodology and Build Constraints
To isolate class mechanics from character optimisation, Szalai constructed standardised, unoptimised Human characters on D&D Beyond using the free 2024 rules subclasses (such as Champion Fighter, Warrior of the Open Hand Monk, and Draconic Sorcerer) and the standard ability score array. Every character took the Skilled feat, which provides no combat benefit, and carried only starting equipment, supplemented by ten thrown weapons or a bow so melee-focused builds could answer airborne targets.
Only 30 of the 105,600 fights at 60 feet ended in a draw, typically from simultaneous knockouts, and starting side had virtually no effect (49.1% win rate for the near side). Because the automated engine uses fixed tactical logic on an open map without cover, magic items, or pre-fight buffing beyond eight-hour non-Concentration spells like Mage Armor and Foresight, the figures represent a controlled mechanical baseline rather than optimal table play.
| Class (2024 Free Rules Subclass) | Win Rate at 30 ft | Win Rate at 60 ft | Win Rate at 90 ft |
| Sorcerer (Draconic) | 75% | 79% | 80% |
| Monk (Warrior of the Open Hand) | 79% | 75% | 74% |
| Wizard (Evoker) | 58% | 62% | 67% |
| Paladin (Oath of Devotion) | 57% | 55% | 52% |
| Cleric (Life) | 48% | 51% | 53% |
| Barbarian (Berserker) | 52% | 49% | 44% |
| Warlock (Fiend) | 42% | 46% | 51% |
| Druid (Circle of the Land) | 43% | 44% | 44% |
| Bard (College of Lore) | 38% | 39% | 40% |
| Fighter (Champion) | 57% | 39% | 34% |
| Ranger (Hunter) | 30% | 33% | 43% |
| Rogue (Thief) | 23% | 26% | 21% |
Stunning Strike and the Level 14 Turning Point
The simulation highlights how single-target control dictates one-on-one D&D combat, where player characters lack the Legendary Resistances that protect high-level monsters.
- Early Dominance: Between levels 1 and 4, the Paladin leads at 77% (peaking at 80% at level 2) thanks to heavy armour and Divine Smite burst damage, while the Sorcerer follows at 68%.
- The Monk’s Lock: From level 5 onwards, the Monk’s win rate surges from 53% to 81%. Under the 2024 rules, Stunning Strike triggers once per turn on a hit for 1 Focus Point, imposing the Stunned condition on a failed Constitution save, or halving Speed and granting Advantage on the next attack even on a successful save. Across a 1,056-duel sample from level 5 up, the Monk landed a stun in 68% of fights and won 96% of those; when no stun landed, its win rate collapsed to 31%.
- Sorcerer Action Economy: Using Quickened Spell to cast two spells per turn alongside Innate Sorcery and Heightened Spell, the Sorcerer dominates levels 9 to 13. Against the Monk, the Sorcerer wins 95% of duels at level 11 and 99% at level 12.
- Disciplined Survivor: At level 14, the Monk gains proficiency in all saving throws and can spend a Focus Point to reroll failed saves. That single feature flips the matchup, lifting the Monk’s win rate against the Sorcerer from 5% at level 13 to 45% at level 14, and 56% by level 20.
Why Fly Fails to Dominate
Despite its reputation as an automatic counter to melee builds, removing Fly from the Sorcerer, Wizard, and Warlock spell lists produced no change whatsoever: across 2,880 fights against the six weapon classes between levels 5 and 19, casters won 69% of their duels both with and without the spell.
In practice, the engine cast Fly in only two of those 2,880 matches. Because Fly requires Concentration, it competes directly with fight-ending spells like Hold Person, Hold Monster, Wall of Fire, and Summon Dragon. When Hold Person lands, which occurred in 3,077 sampled duels, the caster wins 82% of the time (88% for the Wizard). Furthermore, spending an action to take off in an average six-round duel surrenders tempo, and every weapon class carries ranged options capable of forcing Concentration checks. Of 351 simulated flights in restricted-spell tests, 50 ended with broken Concentration and 56 ended with the caster shot out of the air, resulting in 55 losses. Only the Fighter, limited to thrown javelins with Disadvantage past 30 feet, suffers heavily against an airborne opponent (dropping from a 54% caster loss rate to a 73% caster win rate when forced to always fly without control spells).
Starting Distance Reshapes the Fighter
Changing the starting separation from 30 feet to 90 feet alters outcomes most dramatically for the Champion Fighter, which drops from fourth place (57%) at 30 feet to eleventh (34%) at 90 feet. At 30 feet, a Fighter closes the gap and unleashes Extra Attack and Action Surge on turn one. At 90 feet, even a 60-foot Dash leaves the Fighter 30 feet short, handing the initiative advantage to casters, Warlocks pushing them back with Eldritch Blast, or Paladins.
That Paladin matchup highlights a notable 2024 rules quirk. Whereas the 2014 rules required a “melee weapon attack” to trigger Divine Smite, the 2024 spell triggers immediately after hitting a target with a “Melee weapon” or an Unarmed Strike. Because a javelin is classified as a Simple Melee Weapon even when thrown as a ranged attack, The Long Table’s engine allows Paladins to smite on thrown javelins. That interpretation, which remains a recurring point of rules debate on Reddit’s r/DnD and r/3d6, materially boosts the Paladin’s 90-foot performance against Fighters, helping a level 10 Paladin win 78% of those distant duels compared to 51% at 30 feet.
Conversely, the Hunter Ranger climbs from 30% at 30 feet to 43% at 90 feet, though its tendency to hold Concentration on Hunter’s Mark rather than control spells like Entangle or Spike Growth keeps it near the bottom alongside the Thief Rogue (26% at 60 feet), which sacrifices mobility to trigger Sneak Attack via Steady Aim.