Ann Arbor-based tabletop publisher Chaosium Inc. has stopped all development on its crowdfunded board game Call of Cthulhu: Old Ones Origins following the felony conviction of its lead designer, Samuel William Bailey. The publisher confirmed the immediate halt on 15th November 2026 via its official blog and a backer update on Gamefound, roughly one month after the project raised $769,861 from 2,979 backers.

Bailey was convicted on 12th November 2026 in Skagit County, Washington, on multiple felony counts, including first-degree rape of a minor and child molestation, stemming from offences committed between June 2022 and June 2023. Sentencing is scheduled for 10th December 2026, with the offences carrying a possible sentence of life imprisonment.
Chaosium’s Statement and Legal Review
Chaosium stated that it had no knowledge of the criminal charges or ongoing court proceedings until it was contacted on the afternoon of Friday, 13th November 2026. In an official blog post published by Michael O’Brien and mirrored in Gamefound backer update #31, the publisher confirmed it has frozen work while consulting legal counsel on contract termination and backer funds.
Chaosium stated in its public announcement:
These are very serious crimes, and have significant legal implications on the Old Ones Origins board game, beyond the obvious moral and ethical ones. We have stopped all development on this project. We have asked Old Ones Origins backers to please bear with us as we work with our legal counsel as to how move forward. We will be updating this as we get further confirmations.
Because the campaign concluded on Gamefound in mid-October 2026, many backers were enrolled in Gamefound’s StretchPay instalment plan, with the next scheduled payment due on 15th or 16th November depending on time zones. Chaosium noted that it directed Gamefound’s IT team to block the November instalment charge, though the company cautioned backers that technical timing meant it could not guarantee every scheduled payment would be halted before processing. Whether Chaosium will issue full refunds or attempt to salvage the game under a new design team remains unconfirmed pending legal review.
Project Timeline and Mechanics Impact
Announced in July 2026 ahead of Gen Con, Call of Cthulhu: Old Ones Origins was pitched as a two-to-four-player asymmetric strategy board game designed as a spiritual and mechanical reimplementation of Forbidden Stars, the out-of-print 2015 sci-fi wargame Bailey co-designed for Fantasy Flight Games.
| Project Detail | Status / Specification |
| Publisher | Chaosium Inc. (Ann Arbor, Michigan) |
| Lead Designer | Samuel William Bailey |
| Crowdfunding Total | $769,861 from 2,979 backers on Gamefound |
| Conviction Date | 12th November 2026 (Skagit County, Washington) |
| Sentencing Date | 10th December 2026 |
| Development Status | Halted indefinitely on 15th November 2026 |
During the autumn crowdfunding run, the game drew widespread tabletop coverage – both for Chaosium’s strict contractual ban on generative AI artwork and for backer update #13, in which the publisher renamed Shub-Niggurath to Shub-Gorath to avoid automated content filters on social and retail platforms. Bailey, whose previous design credits include Lawyer Up, worked on the title during a multi-year development cycle while criminal proceedings were pending in Washington state.
For the nearly 3,000 backers who pledged an average of $258 each, the immediate question is how Chaosium resolves the financial and intellectual property entanglement. Unlike digital roleplaying game PDFs that can be delisted overnight, a miniature-heavy strategy board game involves sunk tooling, artwork, and platform fees that complicate immediate cancellation.