Hello friends of indie TTRPG news, and thank you for your support. This month, patrons voted Red Ruin Publishing into the Spotlight. If you’re a Patreon, then we’ve a new shortlist for you to decide from.
Your Adventure Awaits
Join Geek Native's patrons and become a hero in your own randomly generated story.
We’ve made it through August, and our sister site, Edinburgh Reviews, still needs to tally up all our reviews, but it’ll be over 100. We kept Geek Native running throughout and now head off to Tabletop Scotland this weekend.
This month we offer thanks to; Daryle Landers, Jake @ Faded Quill Gaming, Chip Mosher, Sean P Kelley, Philippe Marcil, Adept Icarus, Noril of Cold River, R Waibel, Allen Varney, Kate, Paul Wilson, and Heike.
Patrons need only visit this private poll to vote. We appreciate each one.
Here are your choices for next month’s RPG Publisher Spotlight:
To cast your vote and use your Patreon membership, visit this patrons-only page. You star.
Challenging civil power in fantasy worldbuilding
Traditional fantasy worldbuilding defaults to a paradox: gods wield tangible, active power, yet society organises itself exactly like 13th-century feudal Europe. We’ve used this post spotlight essay space to examine this before.
In standard tabletop RPGs, magic is real, and prayers yield quantifiable results. Divine intervention cures pestilence and reknits flesh. Yet while temples are granted a monopoly over hospice care, worldly authority remains stubbornly secular. Nobles control the garrisons. Crown courts mete out judgements. Yeoman farmers cultivate land in comfortable semi-isolation, free from magical coercion until a roving band of goblins threatens the plot.
This model crumbles the moment you take divine reality seriously.
The Monopoly on Violence
Consider a pantheon featuring distinct deities of war and justice. In typical setting design, the Church of the War God provides martial blessings, and the God of Justice inspires wandering paladins. Beyond that, the local baron still collects taxes and commands the men-at-arms.
Why would any sensible martial order tolerate an inept, hereditary warlord?
If a deity actively grants spells that bolster morale, turn steel aside, and smite foes, an army led by that god’s priesthood will consistently outfight secular levies. A noble house cannot compete with a temple that commands both the battlefield and the promise of eternal glory. The church does not merely advise the sovereign; it is an armed, self-funding power bloc with literal divine mandates.
Two logical alternatives emerge:
- Theocratic Monopolies: The Church of War operates the standing army, and the Church of Justice runs the magistracy. Secular monarchs are reduced to administrative clerks. The only check on temple authority is inter-faith tension, such as the War cult demanding aggressive border raids while the Justice priesthood prosecutes their knights for war crimes.
- Aggressive Secular Suppression: Nobles, acutely aware that clerics pose an existential threat to hereditary rule, ruthlessly suppress the clergy. Clerical orders are banned from carrying arms within city walls, temples are limited to strictly ritual precincts, and any priest preaching public justice is executed for sedition.
Leaving armed, spellcasting faiths in a polite feudal equilibrium with mundane aristocrats makes no political sense.
The Myth of the Independent Farmer
The agrarian baseline of most fantasy settings is equally suspect. RPG adventuring parties routinely visit sleepy villages where rustic, independent smallholders scrape by on grain and cabbages.
Agriculture in a world where gods exist cannot remain neutral:
| Fantasy Trope | Political Reality |
| Independent Freeholders | Total Theocratic Vassalage: A community dependent on clerical miracles for rain, blight control, and weed purge cannot afford independence. The local temple holds absolute leverage: tithe properly, obey temple law, or endure guaranteed famine. |
| Noble Feudal Manors | Monopolistic Guild Estates: If druids or Nature clerics can quadruple crop yields with a single ritual, agrarian production shifts into heavily managed corporate monasteries. Small family plots become economically unviable overnight. |
| Mundane Village Security | Hostile Protection Rackets: With wilderness monsters roaming the woods, survival demands real martial deterrence. An isolated farmstead would inevitably be forced to pledge fealty to whichever local temple order could afford to dispatch actual sentries. |
If a priest of the harvest can guarantee a bumper crop while unblessed fields rot, the church controls the entire food supply. In such an economy, the notion of a fiercely self-reliant farmer is a fantasy within a fantasy.
Rethinking civil security along these lines strips away comfortable feudal clichés. The friction between temporal lords, aggressive theocracies, and food-producing cults offers far more tension for an adventuring campaign than yet another predictable hereditary baron.
